Can an employer make permanent staff redundant instead of agency staff?

Yes, an employer can continue to retain agency staff in the same or similar roles to permanent employees who are being made redundant. By doing so, however, it does raise the question of whether or not the redundancies are genuine or necessary, and many employers will come unstuck if they cannot justify retaining agency staff in this way.

After all, an employer would have to justify why fewer people were required to carry out the work, but this is not an easy task if it continues to use agency workers. The position may be different if the employer could show that the agency staff were being retained only, for example, to conclude short term work. At the same, and employer would be saying that permanent employees are not required in those roles under the long-term restructure of the business.

Back to Employment Law FAQ’s

Click here for the main unfair dismissal page

Contact Form

  • How long have you worked for your present employer?
  • Please confirm you have read and understood our “1 day policy”

    Our "1 day policy" concerns the free legal advice service as set out on our free employment law advice page.

    Our one day policy says if you haven’t heard from us within 1 working day of submitting your enquiry, it means we are unable to provide the free service due to existing commitments and your details will be deleted. This provides certainty for you, so you are not left waiting.
    In most cases, however, we are able to let you know the same day, and often within hours if we can take your matter forward.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.